Mercurial Hosting > go2

comparison src/NoAlt.html @ 0:0e911cd3fd2a

Find changesets by keywords (author, files, the commit message), revision number or hash, or revset expression.
add content
author Franklin Schmidt <fschmidt@gmail.com>
date Sun, 02 Apr 2023 10:30:03 -0600
parents
children
comparison
equal deleted inserted replaced
-1:000000000000 0:0e911cd3fd2a
1 <html>
2
3 <!-- Mirrored from users.eniinternet.com/bradleym/NoAlt.html by HTTrack Website Copier/3.x [XR&CO'2014], Sun, 06 Nov 2022 06:49:33 GMT -->
4 <head>
5 <title></title>
6 </head>
7 <body text="#000000" link="#0000ff" vlink="#551a8b" alink="#ff0000" bgcolor="#c0c0c0">
8 <a name="There Is No Satisfactory Alternative T">
9 <p><strong><hr>
10 </strong>
11 <br wp="br1"><br wp="br2">
12 <p><strong>There Is No Satisfactory Alternative To Go</strong>
13
14 <p><strong>&copy; 2002 Milton N. Bradley</a></strong>
15
16 <p>As one of the world's great strategic board games, Chess shares certain important characteristics
17 with Go that also makes it a valuable pedagogical adjunct to the standard curriculum, and it has
18 often been used in that role outside the Orient in places where Go was unknown. As Shelby
19 Lyman noted in his nationally syndicated Chess column in Long Island's premiere newspaper
20 Newsday on Sept 10, 1991, "Chess works in an educational environment because ......it is a
21 sport....and it is played for fun." He continued "... children playing Chess engage their full
22 intellect, will and strength to a remarkable extent. They alertly attend the chessboard: observing,
23 remembering, generating ideas, testing those ideas, making decisions and mistakes and learning
24 from those mistakes." He concluded "Chess has an advantage over most school subjects: it
25 combines both theory and practice. Ideas are honed and tested in the crucible of competitive play.
26 Poor formulation or poor execution of ideas loses games. Careless, faulty thinking is ruthlessly
27 refuted on the chessboard."
28
29 <p>The validity of Lyman's contention that Chess can improve student performance was recently
30 abundantly demonstrated in New York City's Mott Hall School, as reported by Brent Staples in
31 the Sunday New York Times of Dec 15, 2002, and described in considerable detail in the section
32 of this web page entitled "Teaching The New 'R' Of Reasoning".
33
34 <p><em><strong>Go is far superior to Chess as a pedagogical tool because it not only fully shares <u>all</u> of these
35 considerable assets, but also possesses several others of transcendent importance that <u>Chess
36 lacks almost completely</u>:</strong></em>
37
38 <p><UL type = disc>
39
40 <p><LI> Most readily apparent is Go's far greater accessibility, especially by the very young. It is
41 free of all the artificial complexities (e.g. different piece moves, promotion, castling, en passant
42 capture, etc.) that beset Chess. The structure of Go is as simple and almost as easy to learn in
43 rudimentary fashion as Checkers, so it is possible for almost anyone to quickly and effortlessly
44 begin playing it.
45
46 <p><LI> The rigid starting setup of Chess vastly reduces the number of options available, thereby
47 inhibiting the free flow of the player's imagination. In contrast, <em>the Go board starts empty and
48 the players create their own unique structure in every game, thus allowing full reign to their
49 creativity and imagination.</em>
50
51 <p><LI> The simplistic objective of Chess of catching the opposing King together with its small 8 x
52 8 square scale and constricting starting lineup lead to a "quick kill" mentality in which the
53 capture of some material or a successful "mating attack" on the opposing King can lead to an
54 instant win. The result is a game that is very strongly biased toward the tactical, with very little
55 opportunity for the development of much more than elemental strategy. In contrast, the 19 x 19
56 line Go board has enormous scale. Coupled with the need to trade off short term profits and their
57 costs against the possibility of later achieving greater long term gain, this leads to incredibly
58 profound strategy whose realization depends upon the precise execution of tactics every bit as
59 incisive as those of Chess. <em><strong>This gives Go an entire dimension for intellectual development
60 almost entirely lacking in Chess.</em></strong>
61
62 <p><LI> Perhaps most important of all, the vast scale of the Go board makes it impossible to
63 precisely calculate anticipated outcomes during the crucial opening stages of the game, and this
64 requires the players to rely entirely upon general strategic principles and such right brain
65 functions as pattern recognition and "instinct". <em><strong>This integration of right and left brain function
66 provided by Go is crucial to the complete development of the brain, and is also almost
67 completely lacking in Chess (or any other known human activity).</em></strong>
68
69 <p>This unique integration of left and right brain function in playing Go was recently directly
70 demonstrated for the first time by MRI brain scans, in experiments described in the report
71 referenced in the section of this web page "Comparison Between Chess and Go".
72
73 <p></UL>
74
75 <p>For these reasons, <em><strong>Go</em> not only provides <em>unlimited scope</em> for even the most brilliant to
76 exercise their mental capabilities to the fullest, but <em>an effectiveness in improving the brain
77 function and academic performance of even underachievers unmatched by any other known
78 pedagogical mechanism.</em></strong>
79 <a name="Caveats "></a>
80 <p><u><strong>Caveats</u></strong>
81
82 <p>There are some significant caveats that must be addressed in implementing a school Go program,
83 especially in the US:
84
85 <p><UL type = disc>
86
87 <p><LI> Most important is the realization that <em>Go is not a form of magic wand</em>, despite the
88 enormous benefits that its participants ultimately enjoy. Mere brief exposure to the elegant basic
89 concepts of Go and occasional casual play may be pleasurable, but will <u>not</u> result in substantive
90 salutary changes in the student's thinking processes or study habits!
91
92 <p><em><strong>The benefits Go provides can <u>only</u> be achieved over a period of months and years during
93 which the student actively studies and plays Go, and progresses well into the advanced stages
94 of skill.</em> </strong>The reason is that a deep understanding of and ability to appropriately address the
95 complex interactions between Go's strategy, tactics, and elegant structural concepts are what
96 actually improve the student's intellectual capabilities. Coupled with Go's subtle development
97 and inculcation of improved study habits, this then translates into improved academic
98 performance.
99
100 <p><LI> It is this "rewiring" of the brain to enable it to efficiently engage in the kind of <em> advanced
101 REASONING</em> essential to both playing Go and solving real world problems that is most readily
102 accomplished at about age 4 or 5. As noted in some detail in the section of this web page
103 "Teaching The New 'R' Of Reasoning", the ideal learning method for such young children is
104 largely but not wholly informal, supplemented by a small irreducible minimum of formal
105 instruction. Unfortunately, the ideal combination of conditions to permit using this preferred
106 method does not routinely exist anywhere in the US today outside a very few Oriental
107 communities. Therefore there is no practical alternative to a more formal, intrinsically less
108 desirable (but still effective) approach.
109
110 <p><LI> In Japan, Go is a well established and highly respected cultural/social activity and almost
111 every child is already aware of its existence long before entering school, so participation in an in-school Go program is fairly readily obtained and accepted. In the US Go is almost completely
112 unknown to all but a few students of Oriental extraction. Far worse, in our basically anti-intellectual society, activities like playing Go are also often characterized by many students and
113 parents as "nerdy", and are viewed disapprovingly. Overcoming this erroneous negative
114 preconception may constitute a formidable challenge, at least until the program is well
115 established and its value demonstrated beyond question.
116
117 <p></UL>
118
119 <p><a href="SHUNTGO.html"><Font Color="#0033FF"><strong>Continue</strong></Font></a>
120
121 <p>Click Here To Return To<a href="index.html"><Font Color="#0033FF"><strong> Milt's Go
122 Page</strong></Font></a>
123
124 <p><hr>
125
126 <br wp="br1"><br wp="br2">
127 </body>
128
129 <!-- Mirrored from users.eniinternet.com/bradleym/NoAlt.html by HTTrack Website Copier/3.x [XR&CO'2014], Sun, 06 Nov 2022 06:49:33 GMT -->
130 </html>